EDI basics · November 9, 2026

Retail Vendor Scorecards Explained: OTIF, Fill Rate, SQEP and Friends

How major retailers grade suppliers — OTIF, fill rate, ASN accuracy, lead-time compliance — and the EDI documents that feed every metric on the card.

Every major retailer grades you, publishes the grade where your buyer reads it, and prices the misses. The scorecard, not the contract, is your real relationship with the retailer. What surprises most suppliers: the majority of scorecard metrics are either measured through EDI documents or measurable from them — which means the scorecard is substantially an engineering artifact you can control.

The metrics that appear on almost every card

OTIF — On-Time In-Full. The delivery headline. Freight must arrive inside the window (from the PO's DTM dates), complete. Walmart's program is the famous one — misses fined as a percentage of cost of goods, historically around 3% — and Target, grocery chains, and club stores run their own variants under different names. The clock starts at the 850, the window lives in its DTM segments, and a late 856 ASN often counts as a miss even when the truck was on time.

Fill rate. Units-shipped over units-ordered, sometimes measured per line, sometimes per order. Driven by the 855 (what you committed) versus the 856 (what shipped) versus the PO. The graded sin isn't shorting — it's shorting without saying so: an ASN that mirrors the PO instead of the actual pack-out converts an inventory problem into a data-integrity strike.

ASN accuracy and timeliness. Pure EDI metrics: did the 856 arrive before the freight, and did carton contents match what receiving scanned? Serial mismatches between the GS1-128 label and the MAN segment land here. Walmart's SQEP (Supplier Quality Excellence Program) is the fullest expression — a phased program grading PO data accuracy, barcode and label quality, and pallet compliance as their own scored dimensions.

Lead-time and acknowledgment compliance. Did the 855 come back inside the window (24 hours at most majors)? Did you acknowledge changes (860s) at all? Some cards score acknowledgment behavior explicitly; all buyers notice it.

Invoice accuracy. Match rate between 810, PO, and receipt. Low match rates show up twice: as deductions on the 820 remittance, and as an AP-driven score your merchant sees.

Program names, thresholds, and fine schedules differ by retailer and change over time — Target's compliance program, Kroger's grocery variant, and every club and department store have their own — so treat the current vendor guide and portal as the authority on your numbers.

Reading a scorecard like an engineer

The trick is tracing each metric to the document that feeds it:

  • Delivery metrics ← 850 dates + 856 timing + carrier arrival. The controllable slice is the ASN: fire it at ship-confirm, never batch.
  • Completeness metrics ← 855 honesty + SN1 quantities on the 856. Tell the truth early; a downgraded 855 scores better than a surprise short.
  • Data-quality metrics ← label/ASN serial parity, item identifier accuracy, PO round-trip fields. All deterministic; all validatable before transmission.
  • Responsiveness metrics ← acknowledgment latency. Pure automation.

Sorted this way, a bad scorecard decomposes into two piles: physical problems (the truck really was late; the warehouse really shorted) and data problems. The data pile is usually bigger than anyone expects — and it's the pile that goes to zero with a validated, event-driven EDI pipeline, because every item in it is a system producing the same wrong answer on schedule.

The quarterly routine that moves the number

  1. Pull the card monthly, not when the buyer mentions it. Trends matter more than any single period.
  2. Match every deduction to its document trail — the 850, the 997s, the 856 timestamp, the label serials. Dispute the wrong ones with evidence; suppliers with transmission logs win those arguments.
  3. Convert repeat offenses into engineering tickets. A metric that dinged you twice is a process bug, not bad luck.
  4. Fix upstream data first. Item cross-references and ship-to tables feed every downstream metric; they're the cheapest points of leverage on the whole card.

The chargeback-specific playbook is in our guides for Walmart and Target. EDISQ's role in the score is the data half: partner-validated documents, ASNs fired from ship-confirm, label–ASN serial parity built in, and automatic 997s — all on per-document pricing with the first 25 each month free.

FAQ

What is a vendor scorecard?

The retailer's periodic grade of your supply-chain performance — delivery timeliness, order completeness, data accuracy — usually published in the vendor portal monthly, with fines or reduced orders as consequences.

What does OTIF mean?

On-Time In-Full: did the freight arrive within the delivery window, complete? Walmart's version famously fines misses as a percentage of the cost of goods, and most majors run some variant of the same measure.

What is fill rate?

The percentage of ordered units (or lines) you actually shipped. Persistent shorts hurt the score even when everything ships on time — and unannounced shorts, where the ASN claims more than arrived, are graded hardest.

Can EDI improve a scorecard?

Directly. Several metrics — ASN timeliness and accuracy, acknowledgment compliance, invoice match rate — are measurements of your EDI pipeline itself, and the delivery metrics all start from EDI-carried dates.