Every EDI document needs a pipe to travel through, and there are three pipes that matter: VAN, AS2, and SFTP. Suppliers agonize over the choice more than they should, because the honest answer is that your trading partners already chose for you. Still, knowing how the three differ — in cost, control, and failure modes — tells you what you are agreeing to when you sign a routing guide.
VAN: the postal service of EDI
A Value-Added Network is a store-and-forward mailbox system. You deposit documents in your mailbox; the VAN routes them to your partner's mailbox, on the same VAN or across an interconnect to a different one. VANs predate the commercial internet, and they still carry serious volume — Costco and McLane are among the partners that trade through VANs today.
Strengths: one connection reaches everyone, the VAN handles routing and retries, and interconnects mean you never negotiate connectivity partner-by-partner. Weaknesses: cost and opacity. VANs historically bill per kilocharacter — per 1,000 characters transmitted — which makes verbose documents like the 856 expensive and monthly bills unpredictable. Documents also pass through an intermediary on someone else's schedule, so "where is my file" can involve a support ticket.
AS2: direct, signed, and receipted
AS2 sends EDI over HTTPS directly between you and your partner, with payload encryption, digital signatures, and MDNs — signed receipts proving the partner received and decrypted exactly what you sent. It became retail's standard largely because Walmart mandated it two decades ago, and most large retailers now trade AS2 direct; the deep dive is in our What is AS2 explainer.
Strengths: no per-character tolls, no intermediary, near-real-time delivery, and non-repudiation — the MDN is legal-grade proof of delivery that wins chargeback disputes. Weaknesses: you are running infrastructure. Certificates expire, endpoints change, MDN failures need monitoring, and each partner is a separate configured connection. Unmanaged, AS2 is the connectivity option most likely to page someone at 2 a.m.
SFTP: the pragmatic middle
SFTP is a secure file drop: you push documents to the partner's server (or they pull from yours) over an encrypted channel, on a schedule. Target is a prominent SFTP shop, and plenty of 3PLs and mid-size partners prefer it for its simplicity.
Strengths: simple, cheap, firewall-friendly, and every IT team on earth understands it. Weaknesses: it is batch by nature — documents move when the schedule fires, not when the event happens — and there is no built-in delivery receipt. Confirmation that a document arrived and parsed comes only from the 997 acknowledgment, so ack reconciliation is not optional on SFTP lanes.
The decision is mostly made for you
Here is the part the comparison articles bury: connectivity is a partner mandate, not a preference. The routing guide says AS2, or names a VAN, or hands you SFTP credentials — and a supplier with five partners commonly needs all three transports simultaneously. Walmart on AS2, Target on SFTP, Costco on a VAN interconnect: that is a normal Tuesday, not an edge case.
So the real decision is not which pipe but who operates the pipes. Running them yourself means AS2 certificate lifecycle management, VAN contracts with kilocharacter exposure, SFTP schedulers, and monitoring across all of it. The alternative is a provider that operates every transport behind one interface, so a new partner's connectivity requirement is a dropdown rather than a project.
What it costs when connectivity is included
EDISQ takes the second approach: AS2, VAN, and SFTP connectivity are operated as part of the service, across a network of 2,200+ trading partners in the directory. There is no AS2 surcharge, no kilocharacter meter, no per-transport line item — documents are priced per document on the published ladder, first 25 each month free, rates from $0.50 tapering with volume on the pricing page. Whatever the routing guide demands, the answer is the same: pick the partner, and the pipe is already there.
FAQ
Which EDI connectivity method is best?
The one your trading partner mandates. Walmart trades AS2 direct, Target uses SFTP, Costco and McLane work through VANs. Most suppliers with several partners end up needing all three, which is why providers operate connectivity for you.
What is a VAN in EDI?
A Value-Added Network — a store-and-forward mailbox network that routes documents between subscribers and interconnects with other VANs. It's the oldest transport in EDI and historically billed per kilocharacter transmitted.
Is AS2 more secure than SFTP?
Both are secure when run properly. AS2 adds payload signing, encryption, and signed MDN receipts that give legal-grade proof of delivery. SFTP secures the transport channel; delivery confirmation relies on the 997 acknowledgment instead.
Do I have to manage AS2 certificates myself?
Not with a managed provider. EDISQ operates AS2, VAN, and SFTP connectivity — certificates, MDNs, mailboxes, interconnects — as part of the per-document price, so connectivity is configuration rather than infrastructure you run.